From Washington Post
”This new perspective led Manji to write a book titled "The Trouble With Islam: A Wake-Up Call for Honesty and Change." Recently released in the United States, Manji's book challenges Muslims worldwide to end human rights violations committed against women and religious minorities in the name of Islam. She also calls for an end to anti-Semitism, which she says has no basis in the preaching of the Koran. “
You gotta read the book.
“Her critics say the book is simplistic, and that Manji does not have the academic credentials to criticize Islam. "The Trouble with Islam? I think Ms. Manji used the wrong title," said Mohamed Elmasry, national president of the Canadian Islamic Congress, a non-government organization that represents most of the 600,000 Muslims in Canada. "The book should be entitled: the trouble in the life of Irshad Manji. The book is a personal account of a young lady struggling with her religion, which is common among Muslims and non-Muslims. She is not a specialist to advocate Muslims should revise their religion and holy book. It is not credible." “
What's wrong with being simplistic? Her book doesn't need to be complicated because the troubling reality in many of Islamic practices around the world are obvious. I mean you don't need to be a scholar to wonder what's up with the Jewish bashing we commonly hear from them? Why the majority of the world terrorists claim the faith of Islam? Why whenever the Islamist took to power women's right went down the drain?
A specialist? Yeah, like Iran's Ayatollah?
There is nothing sophisticated or new in her book. She simply ask a simple question that has been ignored for way too long amongst Muslims and non-Muslim. “Why?”. Why the killing? Why the hatred towards the Jews? Why the intolerant? Why the oppressive religious regime? The list goes on.
I hope this book ignites major discussion around this country because it is important. We need a real and honest dialogue about Islam. Why can Turkey and Indonesia embrace Islam and stay modern (I have high hopes for Iraq) while its co-religionist in much of Middle East and Northern Africa fail to ride the wave of modern civilization?
I know this can be a very uncomfortable dialog and it can be hijacked by both side of the religioust spectrum, from people that think religion is evil and from people think that Islam is beyond critism. But the questions need to be asked and we ought to answer them, otherwise we are abandoning the aspiration of much part of the world for better living and dignity.