Today is holy Friday, the day Jesus died on the cross, so I think I will use this occasion to write more about what I thought about the Schiavo case.
First my conviction is life is precious and death is not a defeat. It might sounds paradoxical but it is not. Without death, nobody will value life. Death is meaningless if life is not fought and cherised.
Schiavo case is about her wish. It's not about her husband or her family. The conflict we are seeing right now is whether we are willing to trust her husband's version or her family's version. No matter what side we choose, we have to bear the risk of being wrong. There is no way out about it. Being err on the side of line is not better that being err in letting her go. If her husband is right, keeping her alive against her wish will be amount to torture, restraining a soul in a lifeless body in an indefinate amount of time. If her parents is right, we are ending a life that still have a chance.
In Indonesia, we have a proverb for this type of situation. It's called eating the fruit of Simalakama: if you eat it, your mother will die;if you don't, your father will die.
Either way it's a tragedy.
And the only way to deal with such tragedy is with outpouring respect and sympathy from the public to the family. In which many in America, including members of the congress and shameless opportunists have failed to do in this case. Both the husband and the family have been demonized by the harsh spotlight and incessant hubrish of national attention. Do not try to own this tragedy on the back of their pain. No, nobody is trying to kill her.
Stop that.
Now I have chosen side in letting her go. Why? Because I rely the court system in Florida that have handled this case repeatedly over in multiple years to get it right, that her husband's version of her wish is correct. Maybe I'm right or maybe I'm wrong, but this is the only mechanism I can rely my judgement upon right now. I cannot not care so I decide.
Instictively I think removing feeding tube is cruel, but people working in hospice industry have presented a view that it gives a gentle death. Regardless, in this country, removing feeding tube is quite commonm in cases where the person is being let go; Had Schiavo been in visible pain and agony and everybody agree it is best to let her go, removing feeding tube is still the only course of action taken. Every day somebody's feeding tube is being removed.
For me personally, should I ended up in a vegetative state with no chance of recovery, do me one last favour, pull the plug, inject me with with the finest Jack and throw a party on my name; I have always been ready.