"And, of course, that’s what we know as of now. In some cases, it
appears that investigations have gotten...uh...bogged down. But, in any
event, as far as we can tell, out of 108 prisoner death in US Military
custody, at least 27 of them, or 25% appear to be murders committed
mainly by US Military personnel, although in one case, the Justice
Department is investigating since the suspects are CIA employees.
Compare that, to say, 2001, when, in the US corrections system—both
state and federal—homicides accounted for 57 of the 3,311 deaths that
year, or 1.7%. And that, by the way, includes homicides of inmates by
other inmates. The number killed by prison guards, while not broken
out, is no doubt substantially smaller still.
25% v.1.7%"
"Murdering prisoners is wrong. Period. Torturing prisoners is wrong.
Period. Those are, in fact, supposed to be the types of principles that
separate us from the terrorists. But as far as I can tell, there seems
to be some problem getting this message down through the whole chain of
command. It doesn’t matter whether that’s by negligence, or by design,
it has to stop. Even if you don’t care about the prisoners themselves,
you have to at least acknowledge that torturing and killing prisoners
creates a propaganda and moral defeat for our side. It’s unwise on
purely utilitarian grounds, let alone moral ones.
Finally, it’s too bad if it offends you to read criticism of our
soldiers here. But, after putting in 10 years on active duty as a
trigger-puller myself, I’ve pretty much earned the right to make any
criticisms I think are appropriate." (
Qando)